Not All Bloody Mary Mixes Work With Bourbon. Here's What To Look For - Tasting Table

"Some [mixes] are lighter with a more tomato-forward, less nuanced character, while some of the more craft ones are hearty and full of all kinds of savory ingredients. This latter style works with bourbon in that it can stand up to the bigger, bolder flavors."

"Whether it's oaky, smoky, or caramel-forward, all types of bourbon make a Bloody Mary sweeter, and cheap mixes that are mostly tomato juice won't provide enough savoriness to balance out the taste. You especially want to avoid mixes with added sugar, or your cocktail will end up too sweet."

"As bourbon also has some sweeter characteristics, I like to add additional spiciness to balance out those caramel"

Bourbon transforms a Bloody Mary into a bolder cocktail called a Bloody Marianne, but success depends on selecting the right mix. Bourbon's inherent sweetness and caramel notes require craft mixes with savory complexity and multiple ingredients rather than simple tomato juice. Cheap mixes lacking savoriness or containing added sugar create an overly sweet cocktail. Expert recommendations include Toma Bloody Mary Mix with sriracha and chipotle tomatillo, and Bourbon Barrel Foods' mix featuring bourbon barrel-aged Worcestershire and bourbon-smoked spices. Additional spicing helps balance bourbon's sweeter characteristics for optimal flavor.

Read at Tasting Table