"Generally, there's always an argument to be made about who ranks where, and that's certainly the case this year, even with the Patriots. Unfortunately for New England, there isn't a lot of discussion about players not being ranked high enough, as they haven't had many star players on the roster that would bode that kind of conversation, outside of Christian Gonzalez that is."
"That explains why the biggest gripe with the Madden ratings this year is over a mid ranking between Ja'Lynn Polk and Kayshon Boutte. Despite putting up over 500 yards during the 2024 season, Boutte somehow was ranked lower than last year, while Polk, who many even forgot was on the roster last year, somehow went up and is now ranked higher than his teammate."
Every offseason fans anticipate Madden ratings and player rankings across the league. New England lacks many clear superstars, with Christian Gonzalez as a notable exception. The Patriots’ wide receiver ratings prompted controversy after Ja'Lynn Polk’s recent injury and surprising rating increase. Kayshon Boutte, despite over 500 receiving yards in 2024, saw his rating drop and now shares the same overall as Polk. Fans point to the Polk-Boutte midranking as evidence that Madden's rating methodology produces counterintuitive or flawed results. The ratings shift has intensified scrutiny of the game's evaluation process for developing players. Critics question how preseason ratings reflect on-field performance and development trajectories.
Read at Musket Fire
Unable to calculate read time
Collection
[
|
...
]