3 overreactions to the Maple Leafs' early season struggles

"The Toronto Maple Leafs have stumbled out of the gate with an average start to the 2025-26 season, not terrible, but far from the dominant form their fans were hoping for. Their most recent loss to the Seattle Kraken provided the latest feedback, both good and bad, for coach Craig Berube and general manager Brad Treliving to ponder. As the team works to find chemistry and integrate several new faces into the lineup, growing pains were always expected to be part of the equation."

"Still, in true Leafs fashion, every win or loss is magnified and dissected, fueling a wave of hot takes and early-season overreactions. Here's a list of potential overreactions to the Maple Leafs' early-season performance through the team's first six games. Let's separate fact from fiction and assess which concerns are legitimate and which ones might be a bit premature. Team "toughness" remains an issue for Leafs"

"Leafs' netminder Anthony Stolarz was toppled in his crease by the Kraken's Mason Marchment, and there was no immediate response from his teammates. The lack of a reaction has been a long, ugly tradition of this era of Maple Leafs' hockey. Rival players such as Brad Marchand and Sam Bennett have taken liberties with Toronto players with nary a retort. This time, defensemen Brandon Carlo and Jake McCabe were the nearest Leafs' players who didn't respond to a questionable hit on their teammate."

The Toronto Maple Leafs opened the 2025-26 season with inconsistent play, producing average results rather than the dominant performance expected. The recent overtime loss to the Seattle Kraken underscored areas needing improvement and offered evaluative feedback for coach Craig Berube and general manager Brad Treliving. Integrating several new players has produced predictable growing pains through the first six games, which have been magnified by strong reactions from fans and pundits. Team toughness emerged as a tangible concern when goaltender Anthony Stolarz was toppled in his crease and teammates failed to immediately respond. Stolarz has faced frequent contact this season and expressed frustration, and protecting the goalie remains a fundamental aspect of hockey that the Leafs need to address visibly.

Read at Editor In Leaf