Exclusive: NSF puts new research grants to top universities on hold

The NSF Office of Award Management placed limits on new funding to Duke University, Harvard University, Princeton University, and Yale University. An NSF database note states that future awards to these organizations are on hold. Since the hold was applied, little fresh funding has been made available to these institutions by the NSF. The reason for targeting these universities and the duration of the restriction are unclear, and the NSF declined to comment. Legal scholars suggest the restriction may conflict with a federal judge’s ruling that permanently banned similar actions against Harvard. The White House denied that the administration is taking actions against universities it dislikes.

"The US National Science Foundation (NSF) - a major funder of basic research - has restricted the flow of new research grants to a group of elite universities, Nature has learnt. Internal agency documents obtained by Nature's news team reveal that on 9 April, the NSF's Office of Award Management (OAM), which finalizes grants and handles their finances, put limits on new funding to Duke University in Durham, North Carolina; Harvard University in Cambridge, Massachusetts; Princeton University in New Jersey; and Yale University in New Haven, Connecticut."

"A note applied to these universities in an NSF database reads:"Future Awards to Organization on Hold." Since then, little fresh funding has been made available to these institutions by the NSF. It is unclear why the NSF, which has an annual budget of US$8.8 billion, is limiting new funding to these particular universities or when the restriction will end. The agency declined a request for comment from Nature."

"Last year, the administration of US President Donald Trump froze or terminated research funding for several US institutions, alleging violations of federal anti-discrimination policy, such as a failure to protect students against antisemitism. Some institutions struck deals with the administration to restore funds. Harvard, which had about 75% of its research grants terminated by the NSF, sued. A federal judge ruled last September that the terminations were illegal and permanently banned US agencies, including the NSF, from taking similar action against Harvard in the future."

"Legal scholars who spoke to Nature say that the latest restriction on new funding by the NSF could be in violation of that ruling. "The administration has bent itself into pretzels to continue actions against universities it dislikes, even in the face of court orders," says David Super, a specialist in administrative law at Georgetown University in Washington DC. The White House denied that the administration is taking act"

Read at Nature