AOR's 60/40 Allocation Has Lagged a Simple S&P 500 by 60 Points Over a Decade, And Built In Rebalancing Did Not Help

AOR is an ETF-of-funds holding about 60% equities and 40% bonds, charging 0.15% and managing roughly $3 billion. Over the ten years ending mid-May 2026, AOR delivered about 124% total return, while SPY delivered about 261% total return. The gap is more than 100 percentage points, or roughly 5 to 6 points per year annualized. A $100,000 investment in AOR in 2016 would be about $224,000 today, versus about $361,000 in SPY. The bond sleeve has been a drag when yields are elevated, limiting bond price gains. Internal rebalancing can further reduce equity compounding during sustained bull markets by trimming equities to refill the bond allocation.

"AOR holds roughly 60% equities and 40% bonds through a stack of underlying iShares funds, charges 0.15%, and manages around $3 billion in assets. The pitch is diversification, lower volatility, and automatic rebalancing inside a single wrapper. Over a full decade, the bond sleeve has cost shareholders a staggering amount of upside compared to a plain S&P 500 index fund."

"Over the ten years ending mid-May 2026, AOR returned about 124% on a total-return basis. The SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (NYSEARCA:SPY) returned roughly 261% over the same window. That is a cumulative gap well north of 100 percentage points, or roughly 5 to 6 points per year annualized. A 55-year-old who put $100,000 into AOR in 2016 looking for a one-ticker retirement solution has something close to $224,000 today. The same dollars in SPY would be near $361,000."

"The 40% bond allocation inside AOR is the mechanism. When yields are rising or stuck at elevated levels, bond prices stagnate or fall, and the diversification benefit narrows. The 10-year Treasury yield is currently around 4.5%, sitting in the 95th percentile of its one-year range. Yields stayed above 4.4% for long stretches of 2025, which compresses bond returns precisely when equities are running. For an AOR holder, 40 cents of every dollar is anchored to that math."

"Rebalancing inside AOR makes the problem worse during sustained bull markets. When equities outrun bonds, the fund trims winners to top up the bond sleeve. That mechanically pulls money out of the asset class compounding faster and parks it in the one compounding slower. The cost over a decade is visible."

Read at 24/7 Wall St.