Will the new Welsh first minister complete the journey to delivering M4 relief?

An M4 relief road and a possible third Menai crossing have returned to political focus. The first minister says action is needed but has not committed to specific solutions. Without a Senedd majority, cross-party agreement will be required. A full-scale motorway across the Gwent Levels has been ruled out, and the earlier “black route” plan was scrapped due to persistent environmental protections and major cost escalation risk. The government seeks a long-term legacy approach, but voters are unlikely to accept expensive reinventions. Potential alternatives include improvements to the A48, tolls on the M4, expanded bus services and dedicated lanes, and faster delivery of south Wales mainline stations, which would require engagement with the UK government.

"The first minister said "something has to be done" - but it is still not exactly clear what solutions the new Plaid Cymru Welsh government will put forward. Rhun ap Iorwerth does not have a majority in the Senedd, so he'll need to get other parties on board when his government makes up its mind. There are a whole range of options the recently-elected first minister could take - but so far he has committed to none of them."

"But he has ruled out a handbrake turn to revisit the so-called black route relief road, the proposal for a full-scale motorway across the Gwent Levels which was scrapped in 2019 by the previous Labour government. The issues that were facing that plan then are still around today. The Gwent Levels is still subject to environmental protections, and by some estimates the original 1.6bn price tag could have ballooned to 2.5bn the equivalent of almost the entire Welsh government capital budget."

"Plaid wants a long-term "legacy" solution to the problems, but will have to do a deal with parties to get any solution through the Senedd. Previous work which has already looked at two of Wales' most notorious transport headaches is likely to be dusted down - voters are unlikely to tolerate a re-invention of the wheel and its accompanying expense."

"Could this mean road improvements to the A48 which runs through the south of Newport? Tolls on the M4? More buses and dedicated lanes especially for local journeys? Is there any scope to speed up the delivery of new stations along the south Wales mainline, the first of which aren't projected to get underway until 2029? The latter would involve discussions with the UK government, which would fit into Plaid's campaign message that it would stand up for Wales."

Read at www.bbc.com