QYLD's 12 Percent Yield Has Quietly Eroded NAV by 35 Percent Over a Decade While the Nasdaq Tripled

QYLD follows a buy-write strategy that holds the NASDAQ 100 and sells at-the-money index call options each month. The option premium is distributed to shareholders, supported by a 0.60% expense ratio and a goal of high monthly income. This structure delivers regular cash flow but limits gains by capping upside above the call strike every month. When the NASDAQ 100 rises strongly, QYLD keeps the premium and forgoes most of the index’s monthly appreciation. When the index falls, QYLD participates in the drawdown after accounting for the premium. Over long bull markets, the asymmetric outcomes can compound into meaningful NAV erosion, even while distributions continue.

"QYLD launched in December 2013 with a simple buy-write mandate: hold the NASDAQ 100 and sell at-the-money index call options every month. The premium becomes the distribution. With a 0.60% expense ratio and a stated objective of high monthly income, it became a fixture in retiree portfolios and yield-focused taxable accounts. Own big tech, collect roughly 1% a month."

"Writing at-the-money calls means QYLD surrenders any monthly gain in the NASDAQ 100 above roughly 0%. When the index runs 8% in a month, QYLD keeps the option premium and gives back the rest. When the index falls 8%, QYLD eats the full drawdown minus that same premium. Over a long trending bull market in mega-cap tech, those asymmetric monthly outcomes compound against the fund."

"Invesco QQQ Trust ( NASDAQ:QQQ | QQQ Price Prediction), which tracks the same index QYLD writes against, returned 572% over the past 10 years on price alone. QYLD returned 155% on a total-return basis including every reinvested distribution. QYLD's unadjusted share price has declined roughly 35% from a decade ago, which is the NAV erosion shareholders feel when they glance at their brokerage statement."

"The biggest risk facing QYLD is the strategy itself, working exactly as designed. The structure delivers the income. It also caps every dollar of upside above the strike, every month, in exchange. The transmission mechanism that quietly erodes NAV comes from surrendering index gains above the call strike while still bearing downside."

Read at 24/7 Wall St.