Barbecue can be enjoyed any time, including outside warm-weather seasons, and many people keep favorite sauces on hand. A tasting of 18 store-brand barbecue sauces ranked them by personal preference and by overall balance and nuance. The evaluation focused on tang and smoke as primary qualities, with sweetness arriving afterward and adding depth rather than dominating. Trader Joe’s Organic Kansas City Style BBQ Sauce ranked low because it tasted mostly sweet, with only minor tang and smoke that did not elevate it beyond mediocre. Private Selection Memphis Inspired BBQ Sauce matched its promised sweet and tangy profile, earning praise for delivering that flavor direction.
"I tasted 18 store-brand barbecue sauces and ranked them based on my personal preference, as well as how balanced and nuanced their flavor profile was in general."
"This sauce is pretty one-note, and that one note is sweet. You will taste a tiny bit of tang and smoke lingering behind the sweetness, but they don't do nearly enough to lift the sauce out of mediocre territory."
"My ideal barbecue sauce has plenty of tang and smoke, with sweetness coming in behind and a lot of depth to boot."
"I can certainly give some praise to Private Selection's Memphis Inspired BBQ Sauce for delivering the sweet, tangy profile the bottle promises."
Read at Tasting Table
Unable to calculate read time
Collection
[
|
...
]