"As HR leaders, we've all heard it: "The annual review felt like a formality." Or worse, "It didn't really help me grow." Despite the best intentions, too many performance reviews still feel like one-sided evaluations rather than two-way conversations. But it doesn't have to be that way. Top performing teams are flipping the script, using the review as a moment to connect, reflect, and inspire. In doing so, they're strengthening trust, motivation, and retention across their organization."
"So, what does that shift look like in practice? Here's how managers can transform performance reviews from a grading exercise into a growth conversation. 1. Start With Curiosity, Not Scores The biggest shift managers can make is simple but powerful: start by asking employees what they want to focus on. Too often, reviews begin with metrics and ratings, which is a backward look at performance through the lens of a scorecard. While numbers are useful, viewed alone, they rarely spark motivation."
"A recent study found that narrative and forward-looking feedback boost motivation and fairness perceptions far more than ratings alone. [1] Given that only two out of ten employees say their annual review inspires them to improve, [2] creating a dialogue is key to making reviews meaningful rather than mechanical. Instead, imagine a review that opens with, "What would you like us to focus on today?" Suddenly, the tone changes. You're signaling that this is a partnership and that the employee has agency."
Performance reviews often become one-sided evaluations rather than growth conversations. Shifting the focus to employee priorities and curiosity creates partnership and agency. Narrative, forward-looking feedback and open-ended questions increase motivation and perceived fairness more than ratings alone. Regular 1:1 check-ins make annual reviews a continuation of ongoing dialogue rather than a standalone event. Managers should ask reflective questions, practice active listening, and co-create development goals. Emphasizing forward-looking plans, specific examples, and coaching-oriented conversations strengthens trust, enhances motivation, and improves retention. Concrete changes in question style and feedback timing transform reviews into meaningful professional development opportunities.
Read at eLearning Industry
Unable to calculate read time
Collection
[
|
...
]