East Bay Realtor Charged With Murder In Love-Triangle ShootingA man has been charged with murder in the shooting of a romantic rival, claiming self-defense during an altercation.
Seven people deny torturing trans man to death in initial court appearanceSeven suspects charged in the murder of Sam Nordquist, entering not guilty pleas to multiple serious offenses.
Luigi Mangione set for 1st court appearance since his arraignment in UnitedHealthcare CEO's deathThe accused shooter of UnitedHealthcare's CEO is set for a court hearing as he faces multiple charges, including murder as an act of terrorism.
Southport attacker Axel Rudakubana admits murdering three girlsA teenager pleaded guilty to a massacre at a dance class, shocking the UK community and evoking memories of past tragedies involving children.
Luigi Mangione pleads not guilty to murder and terror charges over killing of UnitedHealth CEO Brian ThompsonLuigi Mangione pleaded not guilty to murder charges, including terrorism, in the fatal shooting of UnitedHealth Group CEO Brian Thompson.
Weymouth man pleads guilty to killing father in 2020William Walling Jr. pleaded guilty to second-degree murder for killing his father and was sentenced to life in prison with eligibility for parole after 25 years.
East Bay Realtor Charged With Murder In Love-Triangle ShootingA man has been charged with murder in the shooting of a romantic rival, claiming self-defense during an altercation.
Seven people deny torturing trans man to death in initial court appearanceSeven suspects charged in the murder of Sam Nordquist, entering not guilty pleas to multiple serious offenses.
Luigi Mangione set for 1st court appearance since his arraignment in UnitedHealthcare CEO's deathThe accused shooter of UnitedHealthcare's CEO is set for a court hearing as he faces multiple charges, including murder as an act of terrorism.
Southport attacker Axel Rudakubana admits murdering three girlsA teenager pleaded guilty to a massacre at a dance class, shocking the UK community and evoking memories of past tragedies involving children.
Luigi Mangione pleads not guilty to murder and terror charges over killing of UnitedHealth CEO Brian ThompsonLuigi Mangione pleaded not guilty to murder charges, including terrorism, in the fatal shooting of UnitedHealth Group CEO Brian Thompson.
Weymouth man pleads guilty to killing father in 2020William Walling Jr. pleaded guilty to second-degree murder for killing his father and was sentenced to life in prison with eligibility for parole after 25 years.
Three witnesses testify they heard man confess to 1982 killing of 14-year-old Bay Area girlMarvin Ray Markle Jr. allegedly confessed to a murder committed in 1982 during a welfare check.
Top chef killed in self-defence, court hearsOmar Wilson claims self-defense in the murder trial of top chef Mussie Imnetu, citing fear and regret over the incident.
April trial for Bay Area man accused of killing his missing wifeA jury trial is set for April 28 for Gregory Grant Hobson, accused of killing his wife and disposing of her body.
State dealt early blow in death penalty case. Key witness nixes plea, refuses to testifyTerry Nealy, a key witness, refuses to testify against Anthawn Ragan, complicating the murder trial and impacting his potential early release.
Alleged killers went to pub after stabbing - courtProsecution claims three suspects acted as a coordinated team in the fatal stabbing of Rijkaard Siafa, highlighting their callous behavior afterwards.
Hockey coach and wife were living separate lives' before she was 'stabbed to death'The couple led separate lives, and the marriage had deteriorated before Joanne's tragic death.
Three witnesses testify they heard man confess to 1982 killing of 14-year-old Bay Area girlMarvin Ray Markle Jr. allegedly confessed to a murder committed in 1982 during a welfare check.
Top chef killed in self-defence, court hearsOmar Wilson claims self-defense in the murder trial of top chef Mussie Imnetu, citing fear and regret over the incident.
April trial for Bay Area man accused of killing his missing wifeA jury trial is set for April 28 for Gregory Grant Hobson, accused of killing his wife and disposing of her body.
State dealt early blow in death penalty case. Key witness nixes plea, refuses to testifyTerry Nealy, a key witness, refuses to testify against Anthawn Ragan, complicating the murder trial and impacting his potential early release.
Alleged killers went to pub after stabbing - courtProsecution claims three suspects acted as a coordinated team in the fatal stabbing of Rijkaard Siafa, highlighting their callous behavior afterwards.
Hockey coach and wife were living separate lives' before she was 'stabbed to death'The couple led separate lives, and the marriage had deteriorated before Joanne's tragic death.
Woman accused of holding stepson captive for 20 years pleads not guiltyKimberly Sullivan pleaded not guilty to charges of holding her stepson captive for decades, resulting in severe abuse.
Exclusive | Biological mom of Connecticut House of Horrors victim says seeing stepmom suspect for first time is 'nauseating'The victim's mother expresses her resolve for justice after facing his alleged abuser in court.
Woman accused of holding stepson captive for 20 years pleads not guiltyKimberly Sullivan pleaded not guilty to charges of holding her stepson captive for decades, resulting in severe abuse.
Exclusive | Biological mom of Connecticut House of Horrors victim says seeing stepmom suspect for first time is 'nauseating'The victim's mother expresses her resolve for justice after facing his alleged abuser in court.
Woman said to run Hollywood drug delivery service faces trial - but not for fatal overdoseMirela Todorova's trial highlights the dangers of fentanyl in the drug delivery business, with potential life imprisonment for her involvement in nonfatal overdoses.
Trial date still unsettled for man accused of killing woman, teen girl at Bay Area apartment and livestreaming the aftermathTwo defense attorneys withdrew from representing Raymond Michael Weber, who is accused of double murder and human trafficking.A new public defender was appointed in Weber's case, which includes serious allegations of livestreaming his crimes.
Teen charged with firearms and explosives offencesA teenager faces 26 charges related to firearms and explosives, with a trial scheduled for November.
Woman said to run Hollywood drug delivery service faces trial - but not for fatal overdoseMirela Todorova's trial highlights the dangers of fentanyl in the drug delivery business, with potential life imprisonment for her involvement in nonfatal overdoses.
Trial date still unsettled for man accused of killing woman, teen girl at Bay Area apartment and livestreaming the aftermathTwo defense attorneys withdrew from representing Raymond Michael Weber, who is accused of double murder and human trafficking.A new public defender was appointed in Weber's case, which includes serious allegations of livestreaming his crimes.
Teen charged with firearms and explosives offencesA teenager faces 26 charges related to firearms and explosives, with a trial scheduled for November.
17 attorneys push to disqualify California judge from sex abuse trial, accusing her of a reign of terror'Seventeen attorneys are moving to disqualify Judge Mary Ann Murphy from a child sex abuse trial, citing favoritism, racial bias, and abusive conduct.
Excerpts from President-elect Donald Trump's sentencingTrump received no punishment for his conviction on felony counts, describing the proceedings as a political witch hunt.
From 'secret recordings' to 'sniper rifles' - what the jury in the Diarmuid Phelan murder trial didn't hearDefendant Diarmuid Phelan's defence raised privacy concerns over court artist's presence during pre-trial, stressing the impact of prior threats against him.
Woman (44) who admitted passport fraud to be sentenced next MayA woman pleaded guilty to fraud charges involving false information about her child's paternity and passport applications.
17 attorneys push to disqualify California judge from sex abuse trial, accusing her of a reign of terror'Seventeen attorneys are moving to disqualify Judge Mary Ann Murphy from a child sex abuse trial, citing favoritism, racial bias, and abusive conduct.
Excerpts from President-elect Donald Trump's sentencingTrump received no punishment for his conviction on felony counts, describing the proceedings as a political witch hunt.
From 'secret recordings' to 'sniper rifles' - what the jury in the Diarmuid Phelan murder trial didn't hearDefendant Diarmuid Phelan's defence raised privacy concerns over court artist's presence during pre-trial, stressing the impact of prior threats against him.
Woman (44) who admitted passport fraud to be sentenced next MayA woman pleaded guilty to fraud charges involving false information about her child's paternity and passport applications.
Woman woke to find PhD student raping her - courtThe case involves serious allegations of rape against Zhenhao Zou, who denies all charges including voyeurism and false imprisonment.
Bus driver accused of being high when he killed girl, 9, in BexleyheathA bus driver is charged with causing the death of nine-year-old Ada Bicakci in a crash, allegedly while under the influence of drugs.
Young man to face trial over dangerous driving causing death of his parents and toddler sonA young man faces charges related to a tragic crash that claimed the lives of his family members in Tipperary, Ireland.
Trial consolidation reset for Zizians' charged with a 2022 Bay Area killingJudge rescheduled proceedings for Zizian cult members charged in a murder case.Court tensions arose during the session, especially involving defendant Leatham's behavior.
Exclusive | Hamptons judge chides luxury home designer for 'really offensive' Christmas drunken car crashA judge criticized designer Edward Yedid for a serious drunken driving incident and emphasized strict consequences for future offenses.
Woman woke to find PhD student raping her - courtThe case involves serious allegations of rape against Zhenhao Zou, who denies all charges including voyeurism and false imprisonment.
Bus driver accused of being high when he killed girl, 9, in BexleyheathA bus driver is charged with causing the death of nine-year-old Ada Bicakci in a crash, allegedly while under the influence of drugs.
Young man to face trial over dangerous driving causing death of his parents and toddler sonA young man faces charges related to a tragic crash that claimed the lives of his family members in Tipperary, Ireland.
Trial consolidation reset for Zizians' charged with a 2022 Bay Area killingJudge rescheduled proceedings for Zizian cult members charged in a murder case.Court tensions arose during the session, especially involving defendant Leatham's behavior.
Exclusive | Hamptons judge chides luxury home designer for 'really offensive' Christmas drunken car crashA judge criticized designer Edward Yedid for a serious drunken driving incident and emphasized strict consequences for future offenses.
Businessman appears in court over 10.6m cocaine seizureThe judge has issued a confidentiality ruling regarding the defendant's address in a serious drug case.
Fraudster Samantha Jade Cookes pleads guilty to 60k theft from state after making up illnessSamantha Jade Cookes pleaded guilty to stealing €60,334 from welfare services by falsifying medical claims.
Convicted rapist and kidnapper pleads guilty to harassing female Sunday World journalistsMark McAnaw has a lengthy criminal history and was arraigned for harassment, with sentencing set for March 2024.
Businessman appears in court over 10.6m cocaine seizureThe judge has issued a confidentiality ruling regarding the defendant's address in a serious drug case.
Fraudster Samantha Jade Cookes pleads guilty to 60k theft from state after making up illnessSamantha Jade Cookes pleaded guilty to stealing €60,334 from welfare services by falsifying medical claims.
Convicted rapist and kidnapper pleads guilty to harassing female Sunday World journalistsMark McAnaw has a lengthy criminal history and was arraigned for harassment, with sentencing set for March 2024.
Judge rejects DA petition, preserves death sentence for 1980s Sunnyvale workplace shooterThe hearing regarding Richard Wade Farley marks a significant moment in addressing victims' experiences of workplace violence.
Third man charged with murdering mother and three children in Bradford house fireThree men have been charged with murder after a house fire in Bradford killed a mother and her three young children.
Southport stabbing latest: Axel Rudakubana, 18, admits murders of three girlsAxel Rudakubana has pleaded guilty to multiple counts of murder and attempted murder linked to a tragic stabbing incident at a dance class.
Trial consolidation reset for 'Zizians' charged with a 2022 Bay Area killingProcedural hearings for Zizian cult members Dao and Leatham, charged in a murder case, have been rescheduled amid courtroom disruptions.
Third man charged with murdering mother and three children in Bradford house fireThree men have been charged with murder after a house fire in Bradford killed a mother and her three young children.
Southport stabbing latest: Axel Rudakubana, 18, admits murders of three girlsAxel Rudakubana has pleaded guilty to multiple counts of murder and attempted murder linked to a tragic stabbing incident at a dance class.
Trial consolidation reset for 'Zizians' charged with a 2022 Bay Area killingProcedural hearings for Zizian cult members Dao and Leatham, charged in a murder case, have been rescheduled amid courtroom disruptions.
EcoFactor v. Google: Listen Live This MorningThe Federal Circuit's en banc hearing in EcoFactor v. Google examines the role of expert testimony under Federal Rule of Evidence 702.
Crossbow killer 'raped ex-girlfriend after break-up'Kyle Clifford is accused of raping his ex-girlfriend and murdering her and her family in a premeditated attack.
East Bay siblings sentenced for roles in October 2021 murder of missing Carmel teenThe judge sentenced Jessica Quintanilla to 25 years to life for murder, while her brother received four years for being an accessory.
East Bay siblings sentenced for roles in October 2021 murder of missing Carmel teenJessica Yesenia Quintanilla was sentenced to 25 years to life for fatal shooting, while her brother received four years for being an accessory.
Hayward murder case appears jeopardized after judge suggests very real possibility' jury would acquitJudge doubts murder charge in dispute case suggests self-defense possibility.
Crossbow killer 'raped ex-girlfriend after break-up'Kyle Clifford is accused of raping his ex-girlfriend and murdering her and her family in a premeditated attack.
East Bay siblings sentenced for roles in October 2021 murder of missing Carmel teenThe judge sentenced Jessica Quintanilla to 25 years to life for murder, while her brother received four years for being an accessory.
East Bay siblings sentenced for roles in October 2021 murder of missing Carmel teenJessica Yesenia Quintanilla was sentenced to 25 years to life for fatal shooting, while her brother received four years for being an accessory.
Hayward murder case appears jeopardized after judge suggests very real possibility' jury would acquitJudge doubts murder charge in dispute case suggests self-defense possibility.
Man Pleads Guilty in Fourth of July Parade ShootingRobert Crimo III pleaded guilty to 69 charges, including seven murders, resulting in seven consecutive life sentences without parole.
Enfield woman used array of wigs' to take UK citizenship tests for 13 peopleJosephine Maurice fraudulently impersonated applicants for the Life in the UK Test using disguises to illegally secure immigration status.
Man accused of shooting Bay Area K-9 seeks pretrial mental health diversionDarren Ronald Crail seeks pretrial mental health diversion in connection with the shooting of Vacaville K-9 Officer Murph.
Alexander brothers denied bail by NYC judge in sex-trafficking case, citing flight risk, dangerThe Alexander brothers, charged with sex trafficking and rape, are detained before trial due to concerns about community safety and flight risk.
Mass. Air Force member facing rape charges held without bailA US Air Force member is held without bail on charges of rape and photographing an unsuspecting person.
Alexander brothers denied bail by NYC judge in sex-trafficking case, citing flight risk, dangerThe Alexander brothers, charged with sex trafficking and rape, are detained before trial due to concerns about community safety and flight risk.
Mass. Air Force member facing rape charges held without bailA US Air Force member is held without bail on charges of rape and photographing an unsuspecting person.
Man Arrested for Flatbush Shooting Appears in CourtTwo men charged in a 2017 Flatbush shooting appear in court as legal proceedings continue.
Teenager caught with blood on thumb minutes after stabbing Elianne Andam to death'A teenager was convicted for stabbing 15-year-old Elianne Andam over a dispute about personal belongings, highlighting violent consequences of relationship breakdowns.
What the f**k?!' Violent Midtown subway assault suspect who allegedly stomped on man's head 20 times shocked at bail amount | amNewYorkReyes faces upgraded charges of attempted murder after a severe subway assault, resulting in a massive bail increase.
Alleged Grand Central slasher cries out for his mom at first court appearance for unprovoked NYC attacks: 'I didn't know you were here!'A man was charged with serious assaults at Grand Central Terminal, leading to a courtroom outburst as he faced bail of $150,000.
Three stabbed in the face with wine glass in horror London hotel attackA guest at a luxury hotel attacked staff with a wine glass over denied access to a rooftop bar.
PC saw blood on thumb of Elianne's killer - courtA police officer arrested the killer of Elianne Andam after observing blood on his thumb, marking a crucial point of evidence in the case.
Man Arrested for Flatbush Shooting Appears in CourtTwo men charged in a 2017 Flatbush shooting appear in court as legal proceedings continue.
Teenager caught with blood on thumb minutes after stabbing Elianne Andam to death'A teenager was convicted for stabbing 15-year-old Elianne Andam over a dispute about personal belongings, highlighting violent consequences of relationship breakdowns.
What the f**k?!' Violent Midtown subway assault suspect who allegedly stomped on man's head 20 times shocked at bail amount | amNewYorkReyes faces upgraded charges of attempted murder after a severe subway assault, resulting in a massive bail increase.
Alleged Grand Central slasher cries out for his mom at first court appearance for unprovoked NYC attacks: 'I didn't know you were here!'A man was charged with serious assaults at Grand Central Terminal, leading to a courtroom outburst as he faced bail of $150,000.
Three stabbed in the face with wine glass in horror London hotel attackA guest at a luxury hotel attacked staff with a wine glass over denied access to a rooftop bar.
PC saw blood on thumb of Elianne's killer - courtA police officer arrested the killer of Elianne Andam after observing blood on his thumb, marking a crucial point of evidence in the case.
Attorney faces sanctions filing fake cases dreamed up by AIUncritical trust in generative AI can lead to serious legal errors, as demonstrated by attorneys citing nonexistent cases in a lawsuit.
Blake Lively's and Justin Baldoni's Lawyers Want Each Other to Stop TalkingLawyers for Justin Baldoni and Blake Lively are urged to maintain decorum amid ongoing media comments during their legal battle.
Cab seeks possession of Martin 'Viper' Foley's Dublin home as tax debts total almost 1mFoley is contesting the seizure of his home to settle a €916,000 tax debt, asserting it as their family residence.
Blake Lively's and Justin Baldoni's Lawyers Want Each Other to Stop TalkingLawyers for Justin Baldoni and Blake Lively are urged to maintain decorum amid ongoing media comments during their legal battle.
Cab seeks possession of Martin 'Viper' Foley's Dublin home as tax debts total almost 1mFoley is contesting the seizure of his home to settle a €916,000 tax debt, asserting it as their family residence.
Grenfell Tower fireman squeezed wife's neck while she was drivingDomestic violence can escalate quickly and may occur in public settings, posing risks for children.
Mum of five who died after alleged assault in Galway is remembered as a 'good soul'Sharon Naughton died from injuries sustained at home, leading to her husband's arrest for assault; the community is in mourning.
Grenfell Tower fireman squeezed wife's neck while she was drivingDomestic violence can escalate quickly and may occur in public settings, posing risks for children.
Mum of five who died after alleged assault in Galway is remembered as a 'good soul'Sharon Naughton died from injuries sustained at home, leading to her husband's arrest for assault; the community is in mourning.
Driver in 2022 Deadly Bed-Stuy Hit-and-Run Appears in Court as Victim's Family Struggles With AftermathA man accused of a deadly hit-and-run faces court; the incident severely affected a family.Lindgard Gardner shares the emotional and financial toll from her son's injuries.
The act of a coward': families share pain and anger during Southport sentencingThe article focuses on the emotional aftermath experienced by victims' families following a tragic attack.
Two men (20s) appear in court charged with facilitating organised crime in DroghedaGary Kelly and Dean Thornton are charged with facilitating organized crime through drug offenses and money laundering.
Guilty plea in 'American Nightmare' home invasionsMatthew Muller pleaded guilty to home invasions involving serious assaults, facing multiple life sentences.
Met Police officer to appear in court charged with sexual assaultA Met Police officer, PC Tom Devine, has been charged with sexual assault and is suspended from duty, highlighting accountability within law enforcement.
Guilty plea in 'American Nightmare' home invasionsMatthew Muller pleaded guilty to home invasions involving serious assaults, facing multiple life sentences.
Met Police officer to appear in court charged with sexual assaultA Met Police officer, PC Tom Devine, has been charged with sexual assault and is suspended from duty, highlighting accountability within law enforcement.
Insurance companies fight $19.7m claim over Basquiat forgeriesThe case revolves around the insurability of purported Basquiat forgeries and the insurers' refusal to provide payouts.
Hornchurch man admits to crashing into Buckingham Palace gatesA man caused over £24,000 in damage to Buckingham Palace gates by crashing his car, pleading guilty to criminal damage.
Man charged with stalking Caitlin Clark disrupts court hearingA man was charged with stalking Caitlin Clark and disrupted court proceedings, highlighting ongoing issues of harassment in sports.
MV Matthew: Men due to go on trial for one of State's largest drug hauls apply to have charges dismissedLegal maneuvers may lead to charges dismissed without trials for six men connected to a significant drug haul.
Man admits threatening to kill MPA man has pleaded guilty to threatening to kill his MP, expressing violent intentions during social media communications.
Elianne's killer told friend he was 'evil'Hassan Sentamu, who killed 15-year-old Elianne Andam, had a history of violence and self-described as 'evil' before the attack.
Suspect who stabbed Bronx teen dead tells court the devil made him do it: I'm with Satan!' | amNewYorkWaldo Mejia's erratic courtroom behavior and previous release on assault charges raise serious concerns about the handling of offenders with mental health issues.
Elianne Andam killer had anger issues, court hearsThe case highlights the influence of mental health issues and anger management in violent crimes committed by adolescents.
'I didn't murder anyone' - Man (34) charged in connection with death of Wexford grandfatherWayne Roche is charged with the murder of John O'Connor and has denied the charges.
Man admits threatening to kill MPA man has pleaded guilty to threatening to kill his MP, expressing violent intentions during social media communications.
Elianne's killer told friend he was 'evil'Hassan Sentamu, who killed 15-year-old Elianne Andam, had a history of violence and self-described as 'evil' before the attack.
Suspect who stabbed Bronx teen dead tells court the devil made him do it: I'm with Satan!' | amNewYorkWaldo Mejia's erratic courtroom behavior and previous release on assault charges raise serious concerns about the handling of offenders with mental health issues.
Elianne Andam killer had anger issues, court hearsThe case highlights the influence of mental health issues and anger management in violent crimes committed by adolescents.
'I didn't murder anyone' - Man (34) charged in connection with death of Wexford grandfatherWayne Roche is charged with the murder of John O'Connor and has denied the charges.
Creep hid in south London park at night waiting for woman to masturbate in front ofAaron Black, a repeat sexual offender, was sentenced for terrifying a young woman by masturbating in front of her at a bus stop.
Defense Lawyers Seek to Block Special Counsel Report in Trump Documents CaseDefense lawyers seek to block the release of Trump investigation report, labeling it a politically motivated attack.
Trump Demands Stay Of Sentencing Based On Retroactive Presidential ImmunityJustice Merchan rejected Trump's motion to delay sentencing, criticizing the aggressive rhetoric used in legal pleadings.
Defense Lawyers Seek to Block Special Counsel Report in Trump Documents CaseDefense lawyers seek to block the release of Trump investigation report, labeling it a politically motivated attack.
Trump Demands Stay Of Sentencing Based On Retroactive Presidential ImmunityJustice Merchan rejected Trump's motion to delay sentencing, criticizing the aggressive rhetoric used in legal pleadings.
Man charged with aiding Daniel Khalife after escapeImran Chowdhury charged with aiding Daniel Khalife's prison escape.Khalife escaped by hiding beneath a food van; later arrested after a manhunt.A female accomplice was arrested, but no charges were filed against her.
Probe into Tusla's handling of Kyran Durnin case could take years in the event of a criminal trialThe National Review Panel's investigation may be significantly delayed due to potential court testimonies from social workers involved in the Kyran Durnin case.
Bangladesh: Hindu monk suspected of sedition denied bail DW 01/02/2025A Bangladeshi court denied bail for Krishna Das Prabhu, fearing his release could incite violence due to his past protests supporting Hindu rights.
'I know you're still looking over me': Before he's sent to prison, Antioch man hears from the brother and sister of the boy he killedA man was sentenced to nine years and eight months for causing a car crash that killed a 12-year-old boy and injured two others.
Alleged 'Tom Brady of stealing packages' nabbed in Boston after being spotted by police cadetA Boston police cadet apprehended a notorious porch thief known as the 'Tom Brady of stealing packages' while delivering toys on Christmas Eve.
Man denies attempted murder after girl, 8, and dad shot in Ladbroke GroveA man has denied attempted murder charges stemming from a double shooting involving an eight-year-old girl and her father in Ladbroke Grove.
Knicks legend Charles Oakley grilled over 'missing' texts that could be key in years-long battle against MSG owner James DolanCharles Oakley lost crucial text evidence related to his lawsuit against James Dolan after his phone broke.
Violet Anne Wynne tells court Dail termination payment to be used to towards paying 11,500 WRC award to former employeeMs Wynne intends to pay the €11,500 but cites financial difficulties as a barrier.
Play the lottery for a chance to skip the line, see the Supreme Court in actionThe Supreme Court introduces an online lottery system for public seating, starting February.Live audio of Supreme Court arguments continues as a public accessibility measure.
Woman (50s) dies in hospital days after Co Galway assaultA woman succumbed to severe injuries from an assault in Ballinasloe, leading to an ongoing investigation and legal actions against a suspect.
Solicitor was arrested and driven 240km to court over failure to give ex-client deeds of 1.7m houseJohn Moylan avoided jail by assuring the court he would provide a client with her legal documents.